The Coffee Will Make You Black Reading Group's On-line Chat Transcript for Our April Selection
Publisher: University of Pittsburgh Press Etheridge Knight This Discussion Occurred Check out the current reading list sponsored by |
[tabonnefee] hey Thumper ... how are you this evening?
Thumper6488> Hello tabonnefee, I'm doing well. and you
[tabonnefee] I'm REALLY tired
Thumper6488> You can't be! You da modern black woman.
[tabonnefee] well get over it cause I'm tired!!!
Thumper6488> LOL
[tabonnefee] I can't wait until this school year is over ... I'm too old for
- kids!! ...lol
[tabonnefee] so tell me ... how are you going to discuss this book with out
- the book?
Thumper6488> good memory and excellent wit. *smile*
[tabonnefee] lol...touche
Thumper6488> I thought so. *smile* So how did you like the book?
[tabonnefee] well ... being a writer of poetry I enjoyed looking into his
- world ... I found some of his poems a bit redundant though
Thumper6488> Really? The love poems?
[tabonnefee] even his incarceration (sp?) poems
[tabonnefee] I just think that some of the poems should have been selected
- out due to repetitive themes
>> careycarey has joined channel #XC.1141852
[tabonnefee] and the pictures that his words painted
[tabonnefee] well looky here ...trouble ...lol
>> careycarey has left channel #XC.1141852
[tabonnefee] I must have upset him ...lol
>> careycarey has joined channel #XC.1141852
[tabonnefee] all right Carey ...STAY!!!
Thumper6488> He got on the computer without Miss Ann knowing about it...and
- she caught him on it.
[tabonnefee] lol ... you know you're wrong Thumper!
[careycarey] Okay, I must have hit the wrong key, You can't get rid of me
- that easy!
[careycarey] Hi to you too.
[tabonnefee] well...one can hope....lol
Thumper6488> And yet, we still dream
[tabonnefee] ^5 Thumper ...lol
[careycarey] Pk what's on the table?
[tabonnefee] hello Carey ... how are you this evening?
Thumper6488> ^5 tabonnefee
[careycarey] Just fine ---and yourself?
[tabonnefee] tired
Thumper6488> Hello Carey
[careycarey] Hey thump have I missed anything?
Thumper6488> Nope, we were just getting started.
[tabonnefee] brb
Thumper6488> Carey, how did you like the book.
[careycarey] Well.... It made me feel dumb....haha
humper6488> Hello Carey
[careycarey] Hey thump have I missed anything?
Thumper6488> Nope, we were just getting started.
[tabonnefee] brb
Thumper6488> Carey, how did you like the book.
[careycarey] Well.... It made me feel dumb....haha
[careycarey] I mean I just don't get it most of the time.
Thumper6488> I understand.
[careycarey] I do however have my favorites
[tabonnefee] back ... that's the way poetry is Carey
[careycarey] What about you two?
[careycarey] What do you mean T?
[tabonnefee] at times I believe the only one that truly understands a poem
- is the poet himself
Thumper6488> You know, it took a college english class before I learned how
- to read poetry
[tabonnefee] poetry is highly subjective
[careycarey] But, I still think others must be getting more from this than
- me.
Thumper6488> that could be
[careycarey] How to read portry???
Thumper6488> Yep, how to read poetry.
Thumper6488> I learned in an english lit class
[careycarey] Okay... qick leason please.
Thumper6488> I have to read each word, line and then pause
Thumper6488> Usually, especially with knight, there's more things happening
Thumper6488> than what's at eye level
[careycarey] don't get me wrong I THINK I can think with the best but I
- think theres a rythm I'm missing.
Thumper6488> You could very well be missing it
[careycarey] Yeah!
Thumper6488> I've heard Knight on several occasions
Thumper6488> so it wasn't hard for me to read in the rhythm in which he read
- his poems
[careycarey] That reminds me thump . Does your mother do something in his
- regard?
Thumper6488> What regard is that
[careycarey] Boy, that would help a lot (hearing him)....Does see have a
- knight , night or something
[careycarey] Where did you hear him speek?
[careycarey] speak
Thumper6488> OK, I'm going to come clean. Until he passed, I heard him all
- of my life. He's my uncle.
[careycarey] REALLY!
>> tabonnefee has left channel #XC.1141852
Thumper6488> Yeap. Troy knew all along. He's been keeping it a secret for
- me.
[careycarey] Now that's some interesting S*it.
Thumper6488> Naw, not really.
[careycarey] I will refrain from asking alll the questions that has just
- exploded in my head!...why not really?
>> tabonnefee has joined channel #XC.1141852
[tabonnefee] so what did I miss?
Thumper6488> Well, I never thought of him as really a famous person or
- anything. He was jsut Uncle Jr. to me.
[careycarey] I think I was tipped off by troy, but I wasn't sure. I think It
- was when he asked for e-mails of the regulars.
[tabonnefee] hello?
Thumper6488> Hello
[careycarey] Hello T,
[tabonnefee] lol ...what are the two of you talking about?
[careycarey] Nothing, what poems did you like?
[careycarey] I'll jump in with mine next.
[tabonnefee] uh uhn ... must have been something
Thumper6488> I just confessed to being Knight's nephew.
[careycarey] Forget it girl or look up the list. Haha
[careycarey] T ain't that the s*it?!
[tabonnefee] oooohhhh .. I see Thumper (I'm ignoring Carey)
Thumper6488> Believe it or not, Troy suggested the book.
[tabonnefee] well ...like I said in the e-mail, I'm partial to the haiku
[careycarey] Thump, okay the naptown connection i
[careycarey] T will you explain haiku to me.
[tabonnefee] Haiku is a japanese form ... three lines ...first line is 5
- syllables, 2nd line is 7, and then 3rd is back to 5
[tabonnefee] themes center around nature
[tabonnefee] and it is that nature theme that brings the irony to Knight's
- haiku
[careycarey] Oh.. so why is it a favorite of yours? Irony?
Thumper6488> how so, give us an example
[tabonnefee] I don't find anything natural about what he writes yet it must
- be natural to him
[tabonnefee] or must have been
[careycarey] Whats not natural about his writing...explain.
Thumper6488> what about the hakius concerning Indpls and other cities
[tabonnefee] when I think of haiku and the nature theme I think about
- meandering brooks ... swelling waves ... erratic paths of butterflies ...
[tabonnefee] I don't think of...
[tabonnefee] Easter guard tower
[tabonnefee] glints in sunset;convicts rest
[tabonnefee] like lizards on rocks.
[tabonnefee] so yes...it's the irony that draws me to his haiku
Thumper6488> but wouldn't that be nature to a prisoner?
[careycarey] So why do you think he chose to call them haiku, if they don't
- apply?
[careycarey] Good point thump.
[tabonnefee] carey ...I didn't say that it didn't apply
[careycarey] Okay
[tabonnefee] if you look at my comment earlier I said it isn't natural TO ME
- ...but must have been for him
[tabonnefee] I thought women were the ones that didn't listen!!!
[careycarey] OKAY! *smile*
Thumper6488> Oh, I gotcha
[tabonnefee] his "state" related haiku is a bit more conventional
[tabonnefee] I didn't like those as well
[careycarey] You two will have to excuse me a minute. I have to leave a
- second.
[tabonnefee] ok Carey ... tell Miss Ann we said hello...lol
Thumper6488> and you talk about me....
Thumper6488> smile
[tabonnefee] so Thumper ... you liked For Freckle-Faced Gerald?
Thumper6488> Thanks for bringing that up
[tabonnefee] my pleasure
Thumper6488> did you find out the significance of the first verse
[careycarey] I'm back
[tabonnefee] you'll have to pardon my ignorance with Baldwin ...I'm playing
catch-up in my adult AA reading
[tabonnefee] welcome back Carey
[careycarey] What was tyhe significance thump I have my own thoughts
Thumper6488> The first verse is based on the premise of James Baldwin's
Another Country. In which a black Jazz musician
[tabonnefee] so the answer is no ... I didn't find the significance of the
verse verse
Thumper6488> who has a relationship with a white woman, eventually helps
drive the woman insane and then kills himself by jumping off a bridge
Thumper6488> and that's jsut the beginning of the book
[careycarey] Really, and why do you say that?
Thumper6488> Because the characters name is Rufus and he jumps off a bridge
to kill himself
Thumper6488> And ifyou re read the first verse of For Gerald poem, that's
who he's talking about, I think
[tabonnefee] that's a pretty literal interpretation Carey ... not much of
the imagination needed
[tabonnefee] I would say you're correct Thumper
[careycarey] I thougth the bridge was the tier of a jail house. and he cops
out and kills himself rather than face the others and gerald demise.
Thumper6488> thank you melady. You know I just live for your approval.
*LOL*
[tabonnefee] lol...yeah yeah yeah Thumper
[careycarey] Was rufus not a (tree jumper)?
[careycarey] Rapist?
Thumper6488> I would say that.
Thumper6488> He beat the tar out of her though
Thumper6488> I meant wouldn't
[tabonnefee] Thumper ... is that your sole reason for liking the poem?
Thumper6488> No, actually, I like the whole thing
Thumper6488> the Baldwin reference took me to another level, another depth
Thumper6488> for it brought in another story and dimension to what the poem
was about
ate as
- gerald.
[careycarey] He's a rapist and they raped gerald. Ironic????
Thumper6488> Yes, Rufus committed suicide by jumping off a bridge.
[careycarey] Okay, how does this fit in with the rest of the poem?
Thumper6488> You know Carey, I was wondering if Gerald was raped or not.
[careycarey] WONDERING!
Thumper6488> Yeah
[tabonnefee] I thought he was
[careycarey] It wasobvious to me.
Thumper6488> My interpretation was that suicide was an alternative and maybe
Gerald ought to think
- about it.
[tabonnefee] figuratively and literally
Thumper6488> It was like man, you're gettin' punked, can't whip nobody, and
being raped on top of it,
- just kill yourself
[tabonnefee] how was it an option when the reference to sacrilege was made
...as well as saying that
- Rufus copped out
[careycarey] the reference ot south to north was the tip off. suicide is
always an option but the poem
- didn't suggest that he should.
Thumper6488> good question.
[tabonnefee] hmmm.... poetry ...lots of questions ...few answers...lol
[careycarey] I liked ,the poem It was a funky deal.
Thumper6488> One of the few about Malcolm
[careycarey] Nothing profound just straight funky.
[careycarey] Did you find your book Thump"?
Thumper6488> The funny one was I sing thee of Shine
Thumper6488> No.
Thumper6488> I can get another copy though. *smile*
[careycarey] Thump, isn't here a whole series of shine jokes?
Thumper6488> Yes, but this is the only one I knew.
[careycarey] Thump, I must ask, did Knight fight a drug problem all his
life?
Thumper6488> He use to say it to me and myu cousin when were little tomake
us laugh
[careycarey] Yeah my uncles did too.
Thumper6488> Yes\
[careycarey] How did he die.?
[careycarey] There was a lot of references to drug use, so I thought so.
Thumper6488> Yes, he had a major drug problem. He would go in and out of
rehab.
[careycarey] Did he keep his habit up in jail or pick it up after he got
out?
[tabonnefee] Carey ....which one was your favorite?
Thumper6488> Actually, I believe he got hooked when he was in the Army
fighting in the Korean War
[careycarey] I hae a few T....give me a minute to grab my book.
[tabonnefee] ok
[careycarey] Now my picks a probably not profound ones but they are mine
[tabonnefee] and we will not begrudge you your picks
[careycarey] He they are....Cop-out session.
[careycarey] Belly song
[tabonnefee] I liked Belly Song ... very visual piece
[careycarey] Rehabilitation & Treatment...
[careycarey] and
[careycarey] hard Rock
[careycarey] That's mine.
[careycarey] What do you think?
[tabonnefee] just affective responses?
Thumper6488> I like hard rock too. The English class I took, we study Hard
Rock
[tabonnefee] no real deep meaning to you?
[careycarey] T what do you mean?
[careycarey] How did you study it Thump, I mean whats to study
[tabonnefee] Carey ... did those poems bring up some issues or did you just
read them and think, "I
- like the flow of that one"
Thumper6488> Hard Rock is the one I was taught how to read poetry on.
[careycarey] Of course, they brought out issues Yet it's impossible to
express them here. Really I can
- get into it!
[careycarey] You'd have to hear my voice and all that.
[careycarey] I don't typr welll enough to do my thoughts justice on them.
[tabonnefee] Carey ... poems don't always bring out issues for me... usually
I just like tthe flow and
- the surface meaning
[careycarey] Okay thump, what was there to learn about Hard Rock?
Thumper6488> shoulders hunched*
[careycarey] I see your point T, yet this one was more than surface. I can't
find a flow generally so
- if it's not an issue it gets away from me.
Thumper6488> I learned that I was reading it too fast
Thumper6488> that he described the whole prison experience in Hard Rock,
along with the attitudes of
- the other
[tabonnefee] always read poetry many times ... first run should just be to
take in the words
Thumper6488> inmates and guards and how they related to Hard Rock
[tabonnefee] then read for the flow...ie- punctuation and stresses
ate as
[tabonnefee] then look for symbollic meaning
[tabonnefee] poetry is a mess to read ...MUCH easier to write...lol
[careycarey] Hard Rock was a fallen heroe. He was everything others wnated
to be but couldn't be.
Thumper6488> And what was Hard Rock's downfall?
[careycarey] Mess is right T....at least for me. but I do enjoy some
however.
[careycarey] Down fall??
Thumper6488> Sure
Thumper6488> What happened to Hard Rock?
[tabonnefee] his downfall was his rep...which was erased by the powers that
be
[careycarey] I think he didn't no when to fold'em
Thumper6488> What about the sphyllis he had?
[careycarey] I don't think it was his rep it was who he was.
[careycarey] Did he really have sphyliss?
[tabonnefee] no
Thumper6488> There's a line that explain about his sphyllic spit.
[careycarey] Lets face it . He was just an hard rock brother who others look
up to.
Thumper6488> He had VD and it rotted out his brain
[careycarey] Yeah thump but they also discounted that.
Thumper6488> How?
[careycarey] Please Thump, where'd you get that funk from??
Thumper6488> It's in the poem. I'm not making it up.
[careycarey] Don't make me break the book out on you.
[tabonnefee] I thought the syphilitic spit was more symbolic of some other
societal epidemic
Thumper6488> Carey: did you read this book by yourself? Didn't I tell you
to have Miss Ann read the
- book TO YOU!? *LOL*
[tabonnefee] lol Thumper
[careycarey] Okay I'm reaching for the book.......Actually I read many of
the poems to Ann.
[tabonnefee] what was the need for electroshock therapy then?
[careycarey] Plaese y'all, the boy was simply one of those grade A fools who
the white man had to bring
- down.
Thumper6488> to take the aggression out of him
[careycarey] Yep!!!
[careycarey] Now your talking thump
[tabonnefee] but if syphillis had taken his brain there wouldn't have been a
need for all that because
- he would have died
Thumper6488> Well, I like to think that I was doing that all along. *eyebrow
raised*
[tabonnefee] lol.. you two are a mess
[careycarey] Did anyone like Welcome Back Mr Knight?
Thumper6488> Love of my life!?!
Thumper6488> That one was funny when it shouldn't have been. but I laughed
anyhow
[careycarey] Yes sir.
[careycarey] You laughed, why ...at what?
[tabonnefee] I enjoyed that one...can't say that I laughed though
Thumper6488> Because, it was him. He was being straight up, totally honest
in his portrayal of himself
[careycarey] Oh I forgot Thumper lost his book he might be getting poems
mixed up!
[tabonnefee] I see ...so it was more a laugh from an inside joke kind of
thing?
Thumper6488> It was more a laugh of recognicition (sp)
Thumper6488> How can I tell it.
Thumper6488> Uncle Jr. was the type of Uncle that you read about in books
Thumper6488> the one that always blows into town, you have a good time with
him. and then he leaves
[tabonnefee] that's my Uncle Slick ....lol
[careycarey] Thump, did he have a white women. (usually)
Thumper6488> It was only until I grew up that I recognize how strong he was
Thumper6488> Yes, usually. Much to the dismay of my mother.
Thumper6488> But he had one great love, and she was/is a black woman
careycarey] Some poems seem to be talking about his children is that true.?
Thumper6488> Yes.
[careycarey] Poems from Prison. Is it simular, and have you read it?
Thumper6488> Many of the poems from Poems from Prison is in The Essential
[tabonnefee] so Thumper ... do you favor your uncle?
Thumper6488> The Essential is more like a Greatest Hits book.
Thumper6488> No
[tabonnefee] lol...just checking
Thumper6488> Except for my hair loss, and my ability to cuss
[tabonnefee] LOL...ok
[careycarey] I thought many had a prison vibe.
Thumper6488> but then my father could cuss too
[tabonnefee] honey ...I can cuss too!!!
Thumper6488> LOL
[careycarey] His uncle seems to be slim......*smile*
Thumper6488> Slim?
[careycarey] Never mind.....T-bone lets hear your favorite
[tabonnefee] my favorite? ....hmmm....
[careycarey] And of course you'll have to break it down for us mortals
[tabonnefee] Another Poem for Me (after Recovering from an O.D.)
[tabonnefee] you need to hush Carey
[careycarey] Mum
[tabonnefee] and no,, there is no deep reason ... just felt the words
[careycarey] His uncle seems to be slim......*smile*
Thumper6488> Slim?
[careycarey] Never mind.....T-bone lets hear your favorite
[tabonnefee] my favorite? ....hmmm....
[careycarey] And of course you'll have to break it down for us mortals
[tabonnefee] Another Poem for Me (after Recovering from an O.D.)
[tabonnefee] you need to hush Carey
[careycarey] Mum
[tabonnefee] and no,, there is no deep reason ... just felt the words
[tabonnefee] I felt he was very honest in his words
[careycarey] And????/why. Now that's a cop out.
[tabonnefee] oh well .. .too bad
[careycarey] hahahah
Thumper6488> Careyyyyy, she's tired.
[tabonnefee] lol...thanks Thumper
Thumper6488> Hey, It's time to go.
Thumper6488> We've ran 30 minutes over.
[careycarey] Actually, I enjoyed that also!
[tabonnefee] what's next up?
Thumper6488> Next up is Pictures of A Dying Man
[careycarey] Boy time has past very quickly.
Thumper6488> And the author will be here
Thumper6488> I know.
[tabonnefee] who is it by?
Thumper6488> I enjoyed myself.
[careycarey] Who's the author?
[careycarey] Me too!
[tabonnefee] me three
[careycarey] Who's the author!!!!!
[careycarey] Thump must have lost his book.
Thumper6488> Argymah Kamu
[careycarey] OOOOHH.H
Thumper6488> Agymah Kamau
Thumper6488> Now, so there
[tabonnefee] lol
Thumper6488> Carey are you going to have Miss Ann read you this one.
[tabonnefee] you the man Thumper!!!
[careycarey] Okay you two , It's been fun I'm gone.
[tabonnefee] lol
Thumper6488> OK, you all bye, see you next month.
[tabonnefee] night Carey ... I know it's past your bedtime
[careycarey] Really Thump Why so?
[tabonnefee] night Thumper
Thumper6488> why?
[careycarey] Yep, Why should a
[careycarey] Ann read this one?
Thumper6488> Well, I thought you might need a little help with the print and
all.
[tabonnefee] Carey ... it's not that Miss Ann needs to read it ...she needs
to read it TO YOU!!
[careycarey] See, I thought you were serious. but you are still a
mess...NIGHTY
Thumper6488> Have Miss Ann read it to you in bed, when you're cuddle up with
your fuzzy Ernegizer bunny
- rabbit
[careycarey] BI
Thumper6488> bye LOL
[tabonnefee] night you two